Log in

View Full Version : The End of Philosophy



Patricia1
04-20-2009, 11:58 AM
A Cross Dresser's Manifesto

Last night I found myself tossing around a bit in the small hours of the morning, troubled by some of the turns a few recent threads have taken regarding whom we “think” we are & what we think we’re “doing”, that sort of thing. Some of the thinking expressed betrayed a kind of cracker barrel philosophy and practiced armchair psychology that was somewhat less than professional.

I know who I am and what I’m doing, while maybe unknowing as to the wherefore. As a 6 year who was instinctively drawn to his mother’s bra hanging on the back of the bathroom door, compelled to putting it on and stuffing it with paper and liking the result, I was not thinking of any “ideas” about “loving’ being a woman. I simply responded to a compelling and indefinable urge to do what I did. This epiphany, if a 6 year old can have one, has been the touchstone of my dressing for the rest of my life.

My cross dressing is a behavior, not an exercise in some kind of Socratic search for truth and beauty, looking to find the ideal of “womanhood”. Behaviors of the kind in which we engage are simply expressions of whom we are, just as any behavior tells any observer something about the exhibitor. If my behavior does no harm then it has a validity which needs no defense or explanation, maybe just some light. The fault, dear Brutus, lies not in our behavior but in the eyes of the beholder.

We are gay, we are straight, we are mixed, but we are not confused as to who we are and what we are doing in that state. We may have trouble adjusting our sights to understand the truth about ourselves but we should not apologize for being the way we are anymore than you would apologize for your race, your height, your age or other things over which you have no control and about which any problems with the same are outside your care.

If you’ve come to terms with your behavior and you are self-accepting, then you are well on the way to knowing thyself. By being true to yourself, you can in no way then be false to others to the extent that others know who you are. The only proviso is that you take care to show yourself only when you want to be seen.

I do not intend to offer disrespect to any but ask the same grace from all.

Karren H
04-20-2009, 12:18 PM
Very elequant!!! I was up late last night too... Damn NHL playoffs are killing me!! :)

Ohh and I have accepted myself but have no clue why.. So in reality, I do not know myself in that respect... But then again I don't care to know either..

Jessica Who
04-20-2009, 12:24 PM
Good post. After several frustrating years, I found that trying to compartmentalize everything about crossdressing was improbable. I finally realized that I would never find an explanation or purpose to it, so I relied on the old cliche "it is what it is".

kay2
04-20-2009, 12:26 PM
Thank you for your wonderful post. We are a broad community. As such, what we share across the membership cannot be highly specific. We are here to be supportive of our commonalities. But, just as we use the terms CD, TG, and TS in shifting and overlapping ways, we cannot ascribe to the phenomena universal causes.

billie earls
04-20-2009, 12:40 PM
Patricia 1 that was a great message. Each of us must accept who we are regardless of what tags people put on us. There is no crime in being oneself only in trying to be what others want us to be. It doesn't matter if you are either in or out of the closet all that counts is that you like yourself.

Sophie A Walker
04-20-2009, 01:52 PM
Patricia

Oddly I find myself worrying that my own particular take on psychology/psychiatry might be one of those you describe as 'cracker barrel': I hope it wasn't.

I absolutely agree with everything you say in your post starting this thread.

I think I have guessed the thread on 'being in love with the idea of being a woman' but if I am wrong it doesn't matter the theme is a prominent one at the moment thanks to Bailey and co.

At the moment I am very anamoured with the 'two spirit' idea of the indigenous American peoples. I wish like hell that I had grown up in a culture which had that kind of philosophy about those who cross gender boundaries.

If I had for one thing I would have saved a fortune on clothes and make up as I have had my own fair share of purges.

Reading your post and the replies above I have reminded myself of the stonewall riots, led by drag queens and instrumental in the liberalising of laws concerning homosexuality. Somehow this led also to some adjustment of societies perception of Homosexuality.

The reason I mention it is that I was wondering whether it was now time for a more militant CD/TG/TS attitude. After the Stonewall what really shifted was the gay attitude... It became one where people were able to say to themselves, 'We can fight back! simply by being proud of who we are'.

Thats why I don't purge anymore, I stopped listening to all the social pressures saying that I should be ashamed and started to find reasons to be proud of who I am.

History is a good place to look, a lot of the 'famous gays of history' are not necissarily gay per se, a huge number of them were people who crossed gender boundaries.

We have been around for a long time, we are not going to go away, we have a long and proud history.

There is another thread around at the moment asking 'are you happy to be a CD' I dont think I really understand that question, I am a happy CD/TG/TS not sure which one precisely fits but I might as well ask am I happy to be a person with ears?

What I am though is proud to be who I am and from your post I suspect you are too.

vikki2020
04-20-2009, 02:20 PM
Well said Patricia! These are the threads that I would love for my wife to read :daydreaming: Hopefully someday, but she still refuses for now.

Prissy Linda
04-20-2009, 04:09 PM
I enjoyed your post Patricia... Bravo

Ruth
04-20-2009, 04:36 PM
In answer to your complaint that some of our philosophy and psychology was "somewhat less than professional", the reason is that we are not professionals in the field, as a rule. But we still like to speculate about what's going on.
And it has to be said that the professional psychologists have not done a great job of explaining the various crossdressing behaviors, so why should we not have a try.
Still, if you want to take the purely existential position that you are what you are, and nothing more need be said, that's fine. As long as you are enjoying the situation there's no need to analyse (as Karren often points out).

Charleen
04-20-2009, 08:48 PM
Hey, you kow what? I'm me.Why? Don't know or care.I just know that as far back as I can remember I've known I've had the wrong parts. With the help of this forem I have finally come to accept that about myself while yet admitting that the lack of acceptance in the world is a real problem for us MtF's. The world doesn't seem to care that much about FtM's from what I've seen in the last few years, they rarely get a second look, but let an effeminate looking guy walk down the street.........
I honestly don't know what the answer is for us. Maybe just keep being ourselves and give time time.

bimini1
04-20-2009, 10:16 PM
I started around 6 too. And at the time I also wasn't trying to be a woman. But somewhere along the way I grew and developed into an adult. I changed. I am not that same little boy. It is not the same behavior as it has taken on new connotations down thru the years and without a doubt will undergo even more flux in the years to come God willing.
I feel as though I've grown into something I started way back then but didn't know then what it meant or was about. And in many ways I still don't know. Perpetually going thru different phases and shifting of identities.

docrobbysherry
04-20-2009, 10:33 PM
But, for myself;

I have no idea why I started CDing at age 50+.
I have no idea why it has become such a compelling obsession.
I have no idea when, or if, I can EVER step back from it.
I have no idea if I'm REALLY trans, or simply a CD.
I have NO INTENTION of revealing what I do in private, to people who know me.
I don't lose sleep worrying about, "Why?", anymore.:eek:

But, I am as confused about my CD experience now, as when it began 12 years ago!:brolleyes: