Manly and girlie determined by skirt length?

[Sweetalex]

Manly? NO WAY! That skirt looks great and with legs like that it would be a sin not to show them off! Also i love your boots

[Jilmac]

In your Pic, you look great in your mini however you didn't mention your height which could make you look manly if you're too tall, perhaps a skirt an inch or two longer along with calf high boots would be more femme.

[irenetancd]

Thank you everyone for the comments.
I know very well that the skirt is very short, and I see none of the GG there wore such short skirt. Attention will definitely comes from guys on girls. Luckily, there was no snide remarks during my outing (not that I really care ;p)
What I really like about the SA is she was willing to give an honest opinion, rather than being polite, thus giving me a distorted view. If I had somehow put her in a negative light, the fault is mine and I apologise.
My main intention was to highlight a refreshing view from a GG, and sharing it with others. It does not matter if I completely agree with her view or not, but I am just highlighting a possibly new finding(?) here.
I appreciate the comments from everyone.

[Donniesr]

tell em all to just go the **** to ****...In think you look great...