This conversation took place many years ago when I was single. This was on about the 6th date. I'm shortening it to the relevant sentences.
Me: What quality do you value most highly in a person?
Her: Honesty.
Me: Me too. I like to wear women's dresses.
Her: Seriously?
Me: Yup.
Her: I don't believe you.
Me: It's true.
Her: I can't tell if you're joking.
Me: I'm not joking.
Her: You disgust me.
***********
I wasn't that upset - she thought Sting was really cool.