Oh dear.. so much for shutting up!!
Kimbs... so I'm definitely tg? (Well I guess I knew that even though I doubt/question just about everything at the moment).
But you think I may be in some kind of denial?
Could well be... but, I think it's just because of a whole BUNCH of factors (e.g. the fact that I make a good girl AND boy, wanting to please others, peer pressure(?), body confusion, being so unsure of myself about a lot of things etc etc.
Or do you mean denial either way?
(Don't forget I'm the ship's idiot and need things spelled out lol).
If you mean denial that I'm actually just a normal cisgendered girl... then you could well be right. And that is what I'm afraid of :( I don't WANT to be a normal cisgendered girl.
I won't stop there (the referral) because it's something I need to investigate and sort out (or IS it? Should I just be getting on with being a girl, and I'm actually just fooling myself that I have gender problems? And my only real "problem" is that I want to be cool like I find boys?) ... see how uncertain I get about lots of things sometimes... grrr. Cos that wouldn't explain the "feeling right" about the willy. Although I could have just imagined that it felt right. I worry sometimes I could be so devious to myself subconsciously that I might trick myself into convincing myself of things that aren't true or something....
I am sorry that I am sounding like such a flipping nutcase lol! Constantly stating one thing then another... questioning, questioning. Some of it is because my mum has said to me before that I am the kind of person that picks up on an idea, then won't let go of it. It makes me so unsure of myself... like I can never trust myself to have a true opinion.
I have lately learned that I am right about a lot of things... and become strong in my thinking about certain things that Mum was wrong about (e.g. positive thinking IS the correct way to think, and I was right to be that positive person all along.) Don't forget that I have had a mum with depression on and off for the last 10 years or so ... and at a very impressionable/important time. So some of her thinking has rubbed off on me. (Not being depressed, but self-doubt/insecurities/self esteem issues etc) even though she has always tried her best to make me very confident.
Roberta - wow that's amazing. Very touching. Intense, yet hopeful. Thanks :)
bi - woaah I have thought a lot of those things too...
Especially some days knowing I'm meant to be a boy and some days knowing I'm meant to be a girl, but most of the time being confused lol. You make a good girl as well don't you? Perhaps if we only made a good girl or only made a good boy things would be clearer. Hmm. I'm waffling now. Glad to see I'm not the only one that's questioning and unsure, but still got some sort of gender issues.... My mum thinks I'm a perfectionist (I'm not actually.. just a tad SOMEtimes...) she thinks I feel a huge need to fit into one box or the other. But it's not that. I know I am an exciting blend of genders... it's just the packaging I want it to be in/how I want to bee seen/how I act that is causing me the confusion.
Capt - hmmm. Well do you know what. I think that IS my confusion actually... that I literally don't know whether I am a girl or a boy. If I DID know.... then that would be easier... I think.
Although if I was just a "normal girl" I wouldn't like that (I don't know why). It's like I WANT to be told I'm a boy. Why would anyone want that?! If they had the option of getting on with things as a normal cisgendered person?
Hmm. Maybe it's not even as confusing as I make it, perhaps it's just as simple as:
I don't want to be a girl, I want to be mixture but should I transition, because I would be possibly more comfortable with a male body.
Is THIS what Kimberley means about denial?
Am I OBVIOUSLY mainly a boy... but just don't have the guts to make my outsides match my insides?
Or perhaps I'm OBVIOUSLY just some sort of tomboy that is great at acting and "becoming characters"... perhaps I'm just a CDer.
Oh bloomin heck. (Hmm I don't think it IS denial Kimberley... I think it's out and out confusion._
Like Lisa and Kimb I don't believe that gender has to be binary... although actually it is to some degree at least.
Are there parts of being female that I enjoy?
Well what I like is the attention I get when I have my make up on and people find me attractive (shallow as that sounds) but I think that is the only thing I like about being a girl..
Ok I just thought about it for a moment and I would say that the bits I like about being a girl are as follows:
Because that is who I've been, as my main identity (for whatever reason) for the past {however many} years since puberty.
Female, is how people know me, like me and relate to me. And it's how I know how to be, how I am "trained" to be. (Even though I am a real tomboy as a girl and had a pretty unisex upbringing).
I am actually a bit ugly BUT... I CAN scrub up to make an attractive female and I enjoy the attention of people thinking I look nice.
I like that I can get on with people very well just by being charming and smiley... (but then it p*sses me off when I realise it's just because they find me attractive.)
Maybe my mum was subjected to chemicals or something when she was pregnant with me and it just messed up... so I have an intersexed, and thus, confused brain haha!
Also I seriously think that hormones can cloud your thinking. Perhaps without all this femaleness coursing around my body I would be like "well derr... I'm definitely a boy" instead of this conflict between certain thoughts and feelings I have and my female body.
Or.. maybe when I get slim enough I WILL just feel happy in my own skin as a girl. (No I don't mean that in a weird eating disorders way, I just would prefer to be a little bit slimmer, as a girl).
Quote:
My confusion had to do with how I wanted to present to the world - not because people expect us to be one or the other (I don't care what they expect), but just to see what presentation I'm most comfortable with (male, female, in-between, or changing depending on my mood). I suppose I want to present as male because I got tired of people not being able to see the real me, but I don't have a problem presenting as a girly-boy, 'cause that's what I am. And that's why I'm transitioning, but rejecting suggestions to be more manly where I don't want to be. Does any of that sound familiar?
Yes... that would be why I transitioned too. And also to feel happier and more relaxed in my own skin.
Oh yeah that's another thing too... I (think I) relate far more strongly to being a girly-boy, than to being a boyish-girl. And, as Kerrianna once said to me... there is a difference.
And it can be very frustrating being seen as a boyish girl when in fact you feel like a girly boy lol! But again, I'm not even sure about that.
There's not REALLY much difference in SOME androgynous people, aside from the packaging but then that can impact on how you act and feel.
Ok... I do not want to change who I am as a person. I still want to be "me".
That could well be what a lot of it boils down to.
I am scared that if I transition, I won't be "me" anymore.
Thanks for your help and support guys n gals.
poc oh-so-confused yo
the experiment continues....
Hi, sorry I haven't replied to a few of the answers here. I needed a rest from thinking about it all so much. But I did read all of them and it's good to hear your lovely helpful views and opinions and also to know that I'm not alone with the confusion and that lots of people have felt some degree of confusion over all this gender stuff.
****
Thought I would update this thread with something that happened today...because I was making a video for you guys, with me as "boy poc" (well... more like "androgynous poc" actually) and "girl poc" ... I still had my proper make up on and so I wore it to work and my hair tied back in a ponytail. I got flirted at by so many horrible straight men (haha I'm not saying straight men are horrible in general, but these were), and a bunch of stupid STUPID boys who hung around just to play jokes on me and annoy me, thinking they were hilarious. None of the being-flirted-with/fancied felt nice... NONE of it.
It really p*ssed me off. I'm sure I didn't used to hate being fancied/flirted at by straight men QUITE so much... hmm.
The other day I had my hair in bunches at work and just mascara, this cute canadian guy was talking to me. That's the only person I have enjoyed being flirty with me for ages (he wasn't even that flirty, just sweet).
I just felt like saying "Oh f*ck off and leave me alone you idiots" today.
The cheating continues...
Hehe, there are a lot of people here today, there seems to be some sort of fair on... the roads are busy and there's lots of people milling about, walking up and down and around. Including a bunch of out-of-towners who wouldn't know me from Adam (and so wouldn't recognise me from my "girl mode"). I went out among them, dressed as a boy.
I felt a little bit worried/odd about it at times, which was anxiety carried over from last night I think. (I had a phone call with mum where we discussed TGness again last night and I had ended up feeling quite bad about it all which inevitably evolved into confusion... and worrying about the nature of "me" etc).
Mainly though I felt really nice, sort of relaxed and happy, knowing they were seeing me as a boy. Because I know a lot of them (if not all) did see me as a boy, despite the length of my hair (thank goodness many boys of my style these days have emoey/girly/scruffy/longish hair).
I loved sitting there on a bench in the park while people bustled past occasionally stopping to pet my dog, knowing that not a single curve was showing, and that should anyone happen to look/accidentally notice, that there was a pretty cool bulge showing... if you know what I mean. (Not that they would look, but it made me feel happy/secure/cool knowing it was there! And hey... some people do look sometimes :heehee:).
And I enjoyed people "interacting" (looking, nodding, smiling, whatever) with me as a boy.
*puts hands behind head and sits back and sighs*
aaaaaahhhhhhhh :happy: